Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Junk food bans in school canteens
Karatedo forum > The Dojo > Off Topic
Sionnagh
http://www.thewestaustralian.com.au/defaul...ContentID=15413
QUOTE
Pupils forced to exercise as pies and lollies banned

4th December 2006, 6:15 WST


Children will be compelled to get active and school canteens will have to wean themselves off junk food profits under a new State Government campaign to tackle childhood obesity.

Under the plan announced yesterday, all pupils at government schools from Year 1 to Year 10 will have to do two hours physical activity a week. Currently there is no mandatory requirement for schoolchildren to exercise at school, though most schools have physical activity programs.

Fatty and sugary foods such as meat pies and lollies have been banned from canteens, replaced with items including baked potatoes and dried fruit.

WA School Canteens Association executive officer Robin Bromley said some canteens could face a drop in profits of up to $30,000 when junk food was wiped from menus, but health should be put before profits.

She said schools would have to wind up contracts with companies that supplied items such as soft drinks — which not only brought in profits via the margin above the cost price but also often came with cash-back incentives.

Ms Bromley said canteen services which were contracted out to local stores in country areas or to catering companies would also have to adopt the strict new healthy menu.

She said it might take longer for schools in regional areas to adapt but they would be given time and help to do so.

In areas where fresh and healthy foods were hard to source, schools would be encouraged to link up to form buying groups to increase their purchasing power.

The Government hopes to have the new system in place by the middle of next year.

Alan Carpenter said there would be no specialist staff recruited to implement the twohour exercise regime. Students would be expected to take part in organised sports, dance and physical activity.

The Premier said school principals would have to report on the implementation of the new policies as part of their school review and reporting processes.

WA Secondary School Executives Association president Alison Woodman said many schools were already providing healthy canteen food and had been aware that exercise would become compulsory.


This has started to filter into local schools. Get kids to eat healthier - great! Will this actually work? Not unless they can stop the same kids they're targeting from going to the local shops before and after school and buying there what they can no longer get from the canteen. Not unless they can get those kids to change their eating habits at home. Not unless they can get the parents to change as well.

This sort of policing and removal of choices annoys and offends me on so many levels. It's another example of stupid regulations being implemented because so many people want someone else to take responsibility for things instead of assuming it themselves. It's a token wave-the-flag-look-at-how-much-we're-doing by the government.

It's easier to ban "bad" food than to educate kids (and we dare not suggest parents should have a hand in the education of their own kids) that not only is healthy food better for you but that it can be tasty and also (shame on me for suggesting it) if you eat healthy then you can enjoy junk food without problems.

I give my kids $2 each week for spending at the canteen or shop on whatever they want - it's their "junk food" money. They take their own lunches to school and eat meals made at home most nights of the week. I allow them to buy junk with their $2 if that's what they want. Sometimes they save it and add to their other money to buy something else. They have to choose whether to buy junk with their junk food money. Not only are they learning to budget but they are learning that they have to make choices and they have limits. All things which they will need to know as they get older.

coffeepaper.gif
Mick
Susan
That's fine as far as you and your family goes, as well as many other families out there... But what about those families that don't give two hoots??? The ones that do allow their kids to eat crap food all day every day? The kids don't need to be obese to be unhealthy. They could develop diabetes or an eating disorder for example.

It's easy for us to say educate the children and their parents... But some people just can't be educated or don't want to be educated. Then we end up with a society of fatties or diabetics who use up the medical system for surgeries or procedures that could have been prevented.

There is no need to have so much junk food in schools anyway... I'm sure the change over of unhealthy to healthy products at the canteen comes hand in hand with education about healthy eating and lifestyles anyway.

I think it's a step in the right direction.
Sionnagh
Hmm the trouble is it's no benefit to those that are healthy and have a decent diet. And it's not much help for those at the other end of the scale. Kids do learn about diet and exercise stuff in health classes. But mostly they're stuck with whatever they get fed at home.

A lot of people say they don't have time. A lot of people don't really care about diet. A lot of people simply don't like cooking.

I know people who just can't be bothered when it's only them even though they can cook and know they should make something better than 2 minute noodles.

I don't think the solution is banning foods from schools. But I don't know what can be done.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.